I've never tried a Clos les Lunelles.
I know it's a Perse wine, a person whose rep seems to be improving as Pavie ages better than expected.
Clos les Lunelles is often reasonably priced and highly rated by the snake-oil-salesman par excellence, but does that mean it is Parkerized?
What the BWE take on Clos les Lunelles?
- Comte Flaneur
- Posts: 4908
- Joined: Mon Jan 26, 2009 9:05 pm
- Contact:
Re: What the BWE take on Clos les Lunelles?
I tried it out of curiosity and I think you can safely say that this wine is Parkerized...
This is a bottle with a message in, and the message is 'beware'.
This is not a wine for drinking, this is a wine for laying down and avoiding.
(Borrowed from Eric Idle)
I guess this wine is to Pavie what Lynch Bages is to Mouton Rothschild (or Haut-Brion or LMHB)
I saw it for $47 - I wouldn't say that is cheap for the experience.
I didn't like it. In fact it is a microcosm - a caricature - of everything I despise in modern Bordeaux.
This is a bottle with a message in, and the message is 'beware'.
This is not a wine for drinking, this is a wine for laying down and avoiding.
(Borrowed from Eric Idle)
I guess this wine is to Pavie what Lynch Bages is to Mouton Rothschild (or Haut-Brion or LMHB)
I saw it for $47 - I wouldn't say that is cheap for the experience.
I didn't like it. In fact it is a microcosm - a caricature - of everything I despise in modern Bordeaux.
Re: What the BWE take on Clos les Lunelles?
Yep, spoofulated to the max. I liked the '05 for what it was -- a good wine in a non-expectational way.
BUT, it's a function of what you want in a wine... It may not be classic Bordeaux, but it would be an interesting ringer in a high-dollar Napa cab tasting...
BUT, it's a function of what you want in a wine... It may not be classic Bordeaux, but it would be an interesting ringer in a high-dollar Napa cab tasting...
Re: What the BWE take on Clos les Lunelles?
Thanks for the info.
I bought one bottle of the 2004 (92pts from Parker) for $21, just ITNOS.
I'll post when it arrives.
I bought one bottle of the 2004 (92pts from Parker) for $21, just ITNOS.
I'll post when it arrives.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot], Google [Bot] and 177 guests