TN: 08:.. A very BWE kind of vintage??
- JonoB
- Posts: 1160
- Joined: Mon Dec 07, 2009 7:07 pm
- Location: London, Tokyo, Hong Kong & Gap (France)
- Contact:
TN: 08:.. A very BWE kind of vintage??
2008 Château Lamothe-Bouscaut; Pessac-Léognan
Opened a week earlier by a friend.
smoke, cedar, tobacco, a bit of wood spice and cassis, quite classic on the nose, dried firewood, a bit of dried meat (beef jerky); forest fruit and underbrush, quite leafy with hints of leaf. Sea breeze, salinity and some pencil lead and minerals. Almost a sea-shell and fossil type feel to it, slightly dusty and quite long. Really lovely and drinkable. 68-70/100
Opened a week earlier by a friend.
smoke, cedar, tobacco, a bit of wood spice and cassis, quite classic on the nose, dried firewood, a bit of dried meat (beef jerky); forest fruit and underbrush, quite leafy with hints of leaf. Sea breeze, salinity and some pencil lead and minerals. Almost a sea-shell and fossil type feel to it, slightly dusty and quite long. Really lovely and drinkable. 68-70/100
Jonathan Beagle's Wine Blog
An explanation of my 100 point scoring system
Sake Consultant for SAKE@UK the Sake Import Division of JAPAN@UK
President of the Cambridge University Wine Society 2015-2016
(ITB)
An explanation of my 100 point scoring system
Sake Consultant for SAKE@UK the Sake Import Division of JAPAN@UK
President of the Cambridge University Wine Society 2015-2016
(ITB)
Re: TN: 08:.. A very BWE kind of vintage??
I tasted a lot of 08's at the Paris Grand Tasting last week, and I must admit it seems like a really nice vintage, completely overshadowed by the (mostly-deserved) hype around 09. I think it might be a buyers vintage while everyone is chasing 09.
What's up with the score though?
What's up with the score though?
- Winona Chief
- Posts: 812
- Joined: Mon Jan 26, 2009 9:11 pm
- Contact:
Re: TN: 08:.. A very BWE kind of vintage??
Mr. Beagle's scoring system copied from the link at the end of his post:
Jonathan Beagle’s 100 point system
0-29/100 I wouldn’t bother with this.
30-49/100 Decent but I wouldn’t buy a case.
50-59/100 Good wine showing grape and terroir character.
60-69/100 An excellent example of a wine from this grape, region or country.
70-85/100 One of the very best wines that this region has to offer.
86-100/100 One of the very best wines that I have ever tried, period.
Chris Bublitz
Jonathan Beagle’s 100 point system
0-29/100 I wouldn’t bother with this.
30-49/100 Decent but I wouldn’t buy a case.
50-59/100 Good wine showing grape and terroir character.
60-69/100 An excellent example of a wine from this grape, region or country.
70-85/100 One of the very best wines that this region has to offer.
86-100/100 One of the very best wines that I have ever tried, period.
Chris Bublitz
- JimHow
- Posts: 20672
- Joined: Thu Nov 20, 2008 10:49 pm
- Location: Lewiston, Maine, United States
- Contact:
Re: TN: 08:.. A very BWE kind of vintage??
I'm not big on 2008.
- robertgoulet
- Posts: 684
- Joined: Sat May 01, 2010 12:22 pm
- Contact:
Re: TN: 08:.. A very BWE kind of vintage??
I find that oyster shell/ sea shell quality in quite a few of the pessac's..the '08 larrivet I tasted recently has it..me likey
- JonoB
- Posts: 1160
- Joined: Mon Dec 07, 2009 7:07 pm
- Location: London, Tokyo, Hong Kong & Gap (France)
- Contact:
Re: TN: 08:.. A very BWE kind of vintage??
I glad I have some 08s. I tasted some just after bottling and they were mixed but they seem to be pulling together.
I really want some Poujeaux and Gruaud-Larose.
I really want some Poujeaux and Gruaud-Larose.
Jonathan Beagle's Wine Blog
An explanation of my 100 point scoring system
Sake Consultant for SAKE@UK the Sake Import Division of JAPAN@UK
President of the Cambridge University Wine Society 2015-2016
(ITB)
An explanation of my 100 point scoring system
Sake Consultant for SAKE@UK the Sake Import Division of JAPAN@UK
President of the Cambridge University Wine Society 2015-2016
(ITB)
Re: TN: 08:.. A very BWE kind of vintage??
Jim, what's your issue with 08? Some liken it to 06.
- JimHow
- Posts: 20672
- Joined: Thu Nov 20, 2008 10:49 pm
- Location: Lewiston, Maine, United States
- Contact:
Re: TN: 08:.. A very BWE kind of vintage??
2008 doesn't seem quite ripe to me. More green than the 2006 or 2004. 2006 I consider to be very good, I like the light-on-its-feet character.
- AlohaArtakaHoundsong
- Posts: 1460
- Joined: Sun Sep 02, 2012 5:12 pm
- Contact:
Re: TN: 08:.. A very BWE kind of vintage??
"[Q]uite leafy with hints of leaf". I nominate that for BWE TN of the year.
- Comte Flaneur
- Posts: 4954
- Joined: Mon Jan 26, 2009 9:05 pm
- Contact:
Re: TN: 08:.. A very BWE kind of vintage??
In Jono's defenc(s)e I would say that based on a very narrow tasting of one leftie, le baron, and one rightie, Figeac, the 08s were really classy and as he says a BWE kinda vintage. In both cases the 08 s were generally better than the 04s and 06s. Though in Figeac's case the 06 came close to matching the 08.
- JonoB
- Posts: 1160
- Joined: Mon Dec 07, 2009 7:07 pm
- Location: London, Tokyo, Hong Kong & Gap (France)
- Contact:
Re: TN: 08:.. A very BWE kind of vintage??
AlohaArtakaHoundsong wrote:"[Q]uite leafy with hints of leaf". I nominate that for BWE TN of the year.
That's meant to have been mushroom.
Must have been enjoying the wine too much!!
Jonathan Beagle's Wine Blog
An explanation of my 100 point scoring system
Sake Consultant for SAKE@UK the Sake Import Division of JAPAN@UK
President of the Cambridge University Wine Society 2015-2016
(ITB)
An explanation of my 100 point scoring system
Sake Consultant for SAKE@UK the Sake Import Division of JAPAN@UK
President of the Cambridge University Wine Society 2015-2016
(ITB)
Re: TN: 08:.. A very BWE kind of vintage??
Guys
I consider 2006 to be better than 2008 on the right bank.
The 06s offer more overt red fruits and the 08s can be a bit angular.
Yet 08 to me is a right bank vintage and I have been more impressed by RB 08s than 06 or 04.
04 is good but I think 06 better on LB and 08 on RB than 04.
I consider 2006 to be better than 2008 on the right bank.
The 06s offer more overt red fruits and the 08s can be a bit angular.
Yet 08 to me is a right bank vintage and I have been more impressed by RB 08s than 06 or 04.
04 is good but I think 06 better on LB and 08 on RB than 04.
- JimHow
- Posts: 20672
- Joined: Thu Nov 20, 2008 10:49 pm
- Location: Lewiston, Maine, United States
- Contact:
Re: TN: 08:.. A very BWE kind of vintage??
2006 ranks second to 2002L among my favorite vintages since 2000.
Re: TN: 08:.. A very BWE kind of vintage??
Claudius - count me as confused....is 06 better than 08 right bank, or is 08 a right bank vintage that is more impressive than 06 RB? Or how does that work?
Guys
I consider 2006 to be better than 2008 on the right bank.
The 06s offer more overt red fruits and the 08s can be a bit angular.
Yet 08 to me is a right bank vintage and I have been more impressed by RB 08s than 06 or 04.
- JimHow
- Posts: 20672
- Joined: Thu Nov 20, 2008 10:49 pm
- Location: Lewiston, Maine, United States
- Contact:
Re: TN: 08:.. A very BWE kind of vintage??
Was wondering myself. I think he means 2006 is better than 2008 on LEFT bank.
Re: TN: 08:.. A very BWE kind of vintage??
>>
I consider 2006 to be better than 2008 on the right bank
>>
You meant left bank, right?
Lucie and I drank 2006 Haut Bergey with a cheese soufflé last night. It was noticeably Graves and excellent with the soufflé. Just six months ago it was closed and rather hard.
I consider 2006 to be better than 2008 on the right bank
>>
You meant left bank, right?
Lucie and I drank 2006 Haut Bergey with a cheese soufflé last night. It was noticeably Graves and excellent with the soufflé. Just six months ago it was closed and rather hard.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot], Google [Bot] and 14 guests