St. Innocent thread
St. Innocent thread
Since a number of us are SI fans, I am stating a SI thread to combine notes and comments.
2013 Zenith Vineyard. Zenith is the old O’Connor vineyard and was replanted with the ownership change. The nose has nice spice, a hint of celery, red fruit and forest floor. There is plenty of lemony acidity in the explosive mouthful with secondary development showing mushrooms. Medium bodied with a very long finish, it should get better over the next few years.
2013 Zenith Vineyard. Zenith is the old O’Connor vineyard and was replanted with the ownership change. The nose has nice spice, a hint of celery, red fruit and forest floor. There is plenty of lemony acidity in the explosive mouthful with secondary development showing mushrooms. Medium bodied with a very long finish, it should get better over the next few years.
Glenn
- JCNorthway
- Posts: 1553
- Joined: Mon Jan 26, 2009 9:31 pm
- Contact:
Re: St. Innocent thread
Thanks, Glenn. I will consider this the source of my St. Innocent education since I've been wanting to start purchasing some of their wines.
Re: St. Innocent thread
I've made many posts on SI wines, but apparently not one on 2013 Zenith. The 2013 have just begun to be attractive for drinking IMO. This is one vintage where SI PNs were not sufficiently fruity to be good young.
I am sipping on 2017 SI Freedom Hill Chardonnay while finishing my lunch of leftover grilled shrimp. I like SI PNs much more than SI Chardonnay, but the FH Chard is fine for throwing down. It also ages well, so if you pack some away and forget about them you are rewarded. OTOH, they are not good enough to waste storage space on if you have limited open spots. The 2017 seems to be somewhat lower in acid than usual, but maybe that is because it is rather sweet. It has good holding power and also some minerals. I expect it will improve for several years.
I am sipping on 2017 SI Freedom Hill Chardonnay while finishing my lunch of leftover grilled shrimp. I like SI PNs much more than SI Chardonnay, but the FH Chard is fine for throwing down. It also ages well, so if you pack some away and forget about them you are rewarded. OTOH, they are not good enough to waste storage space on if you have limited open spots. The 2017 seems to be somewhat lower in acid than usual, but maybe that is because it is rather sweet. It has good holding power and also some minerals. I expect it will improve for several years.
Re: St. Innocent thread
I agree on this 13 not being fruit heavy. In fact until the body fills out with some air the acid is rather tart then it becomes more balanced.
Glenn
Re: St. Innocent thread
Following Glenn's lead, I opened a 2013 SI Zenith tonight to drink with baked chicken, tabouleh, and green beans. Glenn's description is very good except that I don't get celery. Mine has the balance of a mature wine, which is not surprising because I stored it at 65-67F, but the resolved tannins are firm. It should provide good drinking over the next ten years at least.
Re: St. Innocent thread
That 12 Momtazi I had from 375 recently was a real head-turner. Riper than I expect SI to be, but none the worse for its overt hedonism.
Can’t wait for fall shipping weather so I can take delivery of my 5 bottles of the 99 Shea.
Can’t wait for fall shipping weather so I can take delivery of my 5 bottles of the 99 Shea.
Re: St. Innocent thread
Patrick, 2012 was a hedonist year for the entire region.Blanquito wrote:That 12 Momtazi I had from 375 recently was a real head-turner. Riper than I expect SI to be, but none the worse for its overt hedonism.
Re: St. Innocent thread
I do notice the celery or dill note in some younger vintages from SI. It does recede and integrate over time. Maybe it is just something I am sensitive to, unlike my inability to detect pepper in most Syrah.stefan wrote:Following Glenn's lead, I opened a 2013 SI Zenith tonight to drink with baked chicken, tabouleh, and green beans. Glenn's description is very good except that I don't get celery. Mine has the balance of a mature wine, which is not surprising because I stored it at 65-67F, but the resolved tannins are firm. It should provide good drinking over the next ten years at least.
Glenn
- Jay Winton
- Posts: 1845
- Joined: Mon Jan 26, 2009 9:06 pm
- Location: Rehoboth Beach, DE USA
- Contact:
Re: St. Innocent thread
I opened an 08 Zenith recently. Drinking well with plenty of life left. Father Stefan made me buy a number of 08 Innocents.
Re: St. Innocent thread
Ego te absolvo a peccatis tuis in nomine יהוה, my son Mr. Vino. Your penance is to drink and report in this thread on an '08 SI PN.
- Winona Chief
- Posts: 808
- Joined: Mon Jan 26, 2009 9:11 pm
- Contact:
Re: St. Innocent thread
Nice showing by the 2015 St. Innocent Temperance Hill at a July 4th outdoor gathering. Great fruit but not too much. Delicious!
Chris Bublitz
Chris Bublitz
Re: St. Innocent thread
Tonight we'll drink 2008 St Innocent Momtazi with grilled steelhead. It shows tart red cranberries on first sip. More later.
I think Mark's Momtazi improved quite a lot since 2008. More recent SI Momtazi have an attractive dustiness and are fuller. 2008 was a great vintage in the Willamette Valley and the 2008 Momtazi is very good, but less impressive than e.g. 2008 SI Shea, which shines with layers of various fruits and sticks in your mouth like taffy. I like the tart red cranberry taste of the 2008 Momtazi that stays the same throughout a meal, and it goes very well with steelhead.
We have, unfortunately, drunk most of our 2008 SI PN, but among those left are a couple of bottles of the 2008 Momtazi Special Selection. I should let them sleep a few more years.
I think Mark's Momtazi improved quite a lot since 2008. More recent SI Momtazi have an attractive dustiness and are fuller. 2008 was a great vintage in the Willamette Valley and the 2008 Momtazi is very good, but less impressive than e.g. 2008 SI Shea, which shines with layers of various fruits and sticks in your mouth like taffy. I like the tart red cranberry taste of the 2008 Momtazi that stays the same throughout a meal, and it goes very well with steelhead.
We have, unfortunately, drunk most of our 2008 SI PN, but among those left are a couple of bottles of the 2008 Momtazi Special Selection. I should let them sleep a few more years.
Last edited by stefan on Mon Jul 13, 2020 1:05 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: St. Innocent thread
For any BWErs who make it to the Willamette Valley in the future, Momtazi is a beautiful winery and well worth the a visit. There are many wineries with beautiful settings, but so far Momtazi has the most scenic location.
Bill
Bill
Re: St. Innocent thread
Tonight with leftover eggplant parmigiana and veal we are drinking 2016 SI Temperance Hill. The bouquet hits you hard and is consistent with the wild strawberry and red raspberry flavors that are accented with a touch of road tar. It is pretty sticky, too.
Re: St. Innocent thread
Tonight I drank 2011 SI Momtazi. On the plus side, it has a nice cranberry taste and pepper on the sides. However, I have not liked any 2011 Oregon PN. They are too thin and acidic, like red Burgundy used to be in lesser vintages. Some who love Oregon pinot noir, including some Oregon winemakers, consider 2011 to be a good vintage for PN. I am not one of these people. For my taste, in this millennium only 2007 is a worse vintage.
Re: St. Innocent thread
Not SI, but last night was 2008 Le Cadeau Rocheux. Just spectacular, one of the best mature OR PN I have consumed.
I find 08 to be drinking well now. It may be time to check on some more 11's.
I find 08 to be drinking well now. It may be time to check on some more 11's.
Glenn
- Chateau Vin
- Posts: 1522
- Joined: Thu Oct 20, 2011 3:55 pm
- Contact:
Re: St. Innocent thread
Stefan et al...
stefan mentioned that he likes both 2014 and 2016 vintages of st innocent, but slightly prefers 2014 to 2016. I was wondering if stefan et al, in your opinion, can shed light about 2012 and 2015 vintages and where they stand in the pecking order when compared to 2014 and 2016...
Also does your pecking order change if the bottling is Momtazi and Zenith?
Thanks...
stefan mentioned that he likes both 2014 and 2016 vintages of st innocent, but slightly prefers 2014 to 2016. I was wondering if stefan et al, in your opinion, can shed light about 2012 and 2015 vintages and where they stand in the pecking order when compared to 2014 and 2016...
Also does your pecking order change if the bottling is Momtazi and Zenith?
Thanks...
Re: St. Innocent thread
CV, my personal preference is 2012, 2014, 2016, 2015, but I am happy to own them all, and the order might well change in time. I place 2013 behind these and 2011 well behind 2013. I have not thought about the orderings for Momtazi and Zenith by themselves, but am reasonably sure that they would not differ much from the above general order. I like SI PN very much and generally make a mental note only when I am let down by one.
Last night I drank 2012 Shea Special Selection and am finishing the bottle now while having lunch leftover from yesterday's dinner (chicken breast and mushrooms over pasta). Not surprisingly, the oak is still overt, but the fruit is powerful enough that I do not mind. My guess is that this wine will peak in 5-10 years, but it is so attractive now that I will continue to open some but I will save 6 or 8 for drinking during its peak years.
Last night I drank 2012 Shea Special Selection and am finishing the bottle now while having lunch leftover from yesterday's dinner (chicken breast and mushrooms over pasta). Not surprisingly, the oak is still overt, but the fruit is powerful enough that I do not mind. My guess is that this wine will peak in 5-10 years, but it is so attractive now that I will continue to open some but I will save 6 or 8 for drinking during its peak years.
- Chateau Vin
- Posts: 1522
- Joined: Thu Oct 20, 2011 3:55 pm
- Contact:
Re: St. Innocent thread
Excellent stefan. I appreciate your take on SI...
On a different note, SI sent an emailer for their 2008 library wines. They cost an arm...
They are asking 240/bottle for their 08 special selection versions...wow...
On a different note, SI sent an emailer for their 2008 library wines. They cost an arm...
They are asking 240/bottle for their 08 special selection versions...wow...
Re: St. Innocent thread
Yeah, I got one, too, CV. I would like to have more 2008s, but those prices give me pause. I wonder if Mark would trade me some in exchange for 2011s.
Re: St. Innocent thread
Tonight I drank 2016 SI Zenith with grilled chicken thighs, tabouleh, and corn on the cob. The Zenith was bright, pure, and straightforward. The tart cranberry fruit is fresh. A bit too acidic with the chicken, it would match well with a fatty salmon and is good with dark chocolate. These 2016s Willamette PNs might not close down.
Re: St. Innocent thread
Bill, have you tried any of those 98 Sheas yet?
Re: St. Innocent thread
No, Patrick. I won't take delivery until late autumn.
BTW: SI currently has a good offer on a bundle of 2016 and 2017 Temperance Hill. I have not tasted the 2017, but the 2016 is very good. It did not show well at release IMO and perhaps did not sell well. I've had it a couple of times during Covid times and was happy to buy 6 more at a bargain price.
BTW: SI currently has a good offer on a bundle of 2016 and 2017 Temperance Hill. I have not tasted the 2017, but the 2016 is very good. It did not show well at release IMO and perhaps did not sell well. I've had it a couple of times during Covid times and was happy to buy 6 more at a bargain price.
Re: St. Innocent thread
My last 02 Anden, the lower portion of Seven Springs which was planted in 1982. Fully mature with mushroom and earthy savoryness. Well balanced with guiding acidity and a long finish. Especially nice with pan seared morels.
Glenn
Re: St. Innocent thread
Wish I had more 2002 SI. stefanJr still has a few, but we cannot get to Oregon for a while.
2015 St Innocent Momtazi. I was afraid that it would be closed, but no, the berry nose is there and the fruit is good. No Momtazi dustiness yet.
2015 St Innocent Momtazi. I was afraid that it would be closed, but no, the berry nose is there and the fruit is good. No Momtazi dustiness yet.
Re: St. Innocent thread
I Repoured 1/4 bottle of 2016 Justice a few days ago. Last night Lucie and I started with small glasses of it. It is an excellent example of Justice, with dark fruit and asphalt. We then drank 2016 Zenith, which is also lovely but very different. This bottle was just like the one we drank a month ago: "The Zenith was bright, pure, and straightforward. The tart cranberry fruit is fresh."
Probably in ten years I will be moaning that we should have saved more of our 2016s, but they are so good now that I have trouble keeping my hands off of them.
Probably in ten years I will be moaning that we should have saved more of our 2016s, but they are so good now that I have trouble keeping my hands off of them.
Re: St. Innocent thread
Last night we drank another bottle of 2016 SI Temperance Hill. This time the wine had a very distinctive and powerful entry of blackberries and black cherries (rather than red fruit) mixed with road tar that shocked our palates. Swishing brought out similar flavors in the mid palate. While very good and interesting, it is one 2016 SI that should be held. I am puzzled that this bottle was so different from the one we drank three months ago. The common feature is the road tar, which I presume comes from the basalt in the soil of TH. Maybe our different perception is do to the food. Last night we ate roasted chicken while with the previous bottle we had eggplant parmigiana and veal.
Re: St. Innocent thread
I got my case today. Looking forward to a 2016 Zenith with lamb chops tonight. Report to come
Best
Jacques
Jacques
Re: St. Innocent thread
I have my opinion about that match, Jacques, and look forward to getting yours.
Re: St. Innocent thread
I have tasted 2014 Shea once and my experience with later vintages is nonexistent.
Tonight I opened 2011 Vitae Springs. This is normally the base wine for Villages Cuvee along with young vine SVD.
Red fruit, mushroom and savory spices on the nose with a hint of herb that later recedes. Initially lots of acidity and lean body which fills out with air. Cranberry and earth in the mouth complete the impression. Good finish. Drinking well with air now.
Tonight I opened 2011 Vitae Springs. This is normally the base wine for Villages Cuvee along with young vine SVD.
Red fruit, mushroom and savory spices on the nose with a hint of herb that later recedes. Initially lots of acidity and lean body which fills out with air. Cranberry and earth in the mouth complete the impression. Good finish. Drinking well with air now.
Glenn
Re: St. Innocent thread
2016 Zenith with rack of lamb and roasted potatoes; this wine is bright with excellent vibrant and juicy red fruit, this is earthy, focused and well structured but with a great balance and a long finish. Actually, the things that strike me more here than anything are the juiciness of the fruit and the impeccable balance. It paired really well with the Australian rack of lamb. I think it will improve with a few years; I expect the fruit to mellow and the earthiness to be a bit more pronounced but it is delicious to drink young.
Now compared to a Bourgogne, I would say the difference is in the fruit (more) and refinement (less).
You guys can keep your Beaujolais, for the same price, imo, this wine runs circles around any Foillard, Lapierre, Thivin, etc...
BTW, the winery shipped it to me in a 10 day FedEx cold storage shipment. Apparently it goes from one cold truck to another for 10 days and arrives before 10:30 am at destination as to not sit on a hot truck all day on delivery date. I had not seen this before and was very please with the shipment.
Now compared to a Bourgogne, I would say the difference is in the fruit (more) and refinement (less).
You guys can keep your Beaujolais, for the same price, imo, this wine runs circles around any Foillard, Lapierre, Thivin, etc...
BTW, the winery shipped it to me in a 10 day FedEx cold storage shipment. Apparently it goes from one cold truck to another for 10 days and arrives before 10:30 am at destination as to not sit on a hot truck all day on delivery date. I had not seen this before and was very please with the shipment.
Best
Jacques
Jacques
- JimHow
- Posts: 20263
- Joined: Thu Nov 20, 2008 10:49 pm
- Location: Lewiston, Maine, United States
- Contact:
Re: St. Innocent thread
I'm looking for that mixed case list you bought, Jacques....
- JimHow
- Posts: 20263
- Joined: Thu Nov 20, 2008 10:49 pm
- Location: Lewiston, Maine, United States
- Contact:
Re: St. Innocent thread
Found it. Just ordered a mixed case.
Re: St. Innocent thread
Glenn, is it OK to post on other Oregon wines in this thread?
Tonight I opened a 2014 Penner-Ash Pinot Noir to drink with sautéed mushrooms over turnip mashed potatoes. This is a blend rather than a single vineyard wine. My first impression was that it contained so much candied fruit that I must have opened a CA PN by mistake. It got better, but this wine is worse than all other OR PNs I have drunk in the last year, which is to say that it is a decent wine. SI's blended PN, Village Cuvee, is decidedly better and costs 1/3 less.
Tonight I opened a 2014 Penner-Ash Pinot Noir to drink with sautéed mushrooms over turnip mashed potatoes. This is a blend rather than a single vineyard wine. My first impression was that it contained so much candied fruit that I must have opened a CA PN by mistake. It got better, but this wine is worse than all other OR PNs I have drunk in the last year, which is to say that it is a decent wine. SI's blended PN, Village Cuvee, is decidedly better and costs 1/3 less.
Re: St. Innocent thread
With duck legs braised with vegetables we drank 2012 SI Zenith Special Selection. This is very pure and bright, with flavors of red raspberries, strawberries. Excellent for the vineyard and drinking well already; more mature than the Shea.
- JimHow
- Posts: 20263
- Joined: Thu Nov 20, 2008 10:49 pm
- Location: Lewiston, Maine, United States
- Contact:
Re: St. Innocent thread
Felice confirmed she's shipping out my mixed case order of:
2015 Freedom Hill x 3
2016 Justice x 1
2016 Momtazi x 6
2016 Temperance Hill x 1
2016 Zenith x 1
2015 Freedom Hill x 3
2016 Justice x 1
2016 Momtazi x 6
2016 Temperance Hill x 1
2016 Zenith x 1
- JCNorthway
- Posts: 1553
- Joined: Mon Jan 26, 2009 9:31 pm
- Contact:
Re: St. Innocent thread
So Jim, is that the "club" case that comes twice a year, or were you able to pick the wines you wanted without being a club member?
- JimHow
- Posts: 20263
- Joined: Thu Nov 20, 2008 10:49 pm
- Location: Lewiston, Maine, United States
- Contact:
Re: St. Innocent thread
Yes that right, Jon, I'm not a club member, you get 15% off if you order a mixed case of 12 bottles.
Re: St. Innocent thread
This thread is open to all Oregon wines.stefan wrote:Glenn, is it OK to post on other Oregon wines in this thread?
Tonight I opened a 2014 Penner-Ash Pinot Noir to drink with sautéed mushrooms over turnip mashed potatoes. This is a blend rather than a single vineyard wine. My first impression was that it contained so much candied fruit that I must have opened a CA PN by mistake. It got better, but this wine is worse than all other OR PNs I have drunk in the last year, which is to say that it is a decent wine. SI's blended PN, Village Cuvee, is decidedly better and costs 1/3 less.
Glenn
Re: St. Innocent thread
I had the 2013 Shea last night. For me the 2013 has been a problem child since its release. It was rough and disjointed. Finally last night the wine had melded and was drinking beautifully. I was showing some signs of maturity but it was far from over the hill. No formal notes but it is in a much better place than it was upon release.
Regarding Penner Ash, it's always been on the heavy extraction side. Further it's always over-priced. It is now owned by the Jackson Family Wines who first brought you Kendall Jackson Chard. As I recall from my last visit, they own at least three Willamette wineries.
Bil
Regarding Penner Ash, it's always been on the heavy extraction side. Further it's always over-priced. It is now owned by the Jackson Family Wines who first brought you Kendall Jackson Chard. As I recall from my last visit, they own at least three Willamette wineries.
Bil
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot] and 41 guests