Bordeaux Wine Enthusiasts

stefan

Great wine for celebrating your 80th birthday! One lot I lost in my last auction outing contained a bottle of '89 Lynch Bages. I hope it found a good home.

stefan

>>
I frequently use the plus sign when assigning a score as I am grading the wine in its current state while acknowledging that there is room for future improvement.
>>

Yes, I do the same.

stefan

Wine enough for after you turn 90, but what about when you are in your seventies and eighties?

stefan

>> ...poor, average, good, very good, and superlative... I took my lead from the late Clive Coates MW... >> Clive also used "very fine indeed", "quite good", and the like. IIRC, "quite good" was less than "good" and "very fine indeed" was better than...

stefan

I need whites for Texas, but I do not like the selection available locally. Lucie agreed that we can substitute Champagne, so I bought

3 Clouet Silver
1 Clouet Rose
2 2016 Trudon

stefan

>>
Lafite has always held a mystique for me
>>

For me, too. No other first growth has it. It reminds me of Salieri versus Mozart: Salieri crafts a perfect composition, then a Mozart piece blows it away.

stefan

Congratulations! That's a great score. Thinking about drinking them at maturiy will help you stay alive.

stefan

>> i will never understand the 86 PichonLalande >> My experience with the 86 Comtesse has been very good. '78 Giscours and '67 Haut Brion bring back good memories for me. The last few bottles of '86 Gruaud we have drunk have varied from very good to outstanding. For some reason I am insensitive to t...

stefan

I could not find a wine list for Le Bernardin. Is there one online?

stefan

The food part of the menu looks great; glad it was great. I did not know that Lambray made a Folatieres. Did the Som decant it? Papa Doc was a fan of decanting white Burgundies, and I should have followed his advice tonight. We drank a 2017 Berthelemot Chassagne Abbaye de Morgeot with pan fried flou...

stefan

$691 tax free is a very good price for 2016 Lafite, Jim. I doubt that you could get that price at auction.

>>
I can't take them with me
>>

Are you sure? Save one to share with me in That Great Tasting Room in the Sky.

stefan

About the same, Jim, as the 1996, and hard to get at auctions for under $900 all in. Probably considerably less in the UK at auctions; right, Ian? Occasionally at USA auctions you can get "bargains" on Lafite. My most recent purchase was the equivalent of $410/ bottle all in for the 1983 L...

stefan

1996 at USA retail is $900-$1300.

stefan

I drink a lot of La Tour Blanche, partly because I like and partly because it is the favorite Sauternes of a friend. I appreciate the 2003, but I am not surprised that it did not go well with foie gras. IMO, it is a wine to drink by itself or with a salty cheese or salted popcorn.

stefan

Excellent comparison report, Mark!

Most notable for me is how Prieure Lichine has improved over the years.

stefan

I agree, Ian.

The 2010 il Poggione is still primary, but the Bolognese sauce smooths it out. I saved some to drink tomorrow at lunch.

stefan

I thought about drinking a 2010 Bruna Grimaldi Camilla tonight but instead instead opened a 2010 il Poggione Brunello. I think it will be better with pasta Bolognese.

stefan

I expected to win at most 2-3 lots in a recent online auction. However,.... Chateau Pichon Lalande 1996 Pauillac lscl Bottle (1) 2000 Pauillac 2nl Bottle (2) Chateau Gruaud Larose 1986 St. Julien ts, scl Bottle (1) Chateau Clinet 1995 Pomerol lscl Bottle (1) Chateau Cos d'Estournel 1996 St. Estephe ...

stefan

I hope you are past the worst phase and continue to improve, Danny. Are you able to play 18 now?

stefan

Oh, maybe that explains why you got so sick. You were green most of the next day IIRC.

stefan

A Zinfandel with a steak? And you claim to be a Bordeaux Wine Enthusiast? Any self respecting BWEer would be drinking a Pauillac with the steak.

What is your excuse?

stefan

I wrote the above before starting to eat. Pairing the 2014 Cantemerle with a ground venison dish Lucie prepared was a good choice as the venison smoothed out the rough edges in the Cantemerle.

stefan

>> JC is one of the very first original BWEers, we met him and his amazing better half Paula in Chicago in February 2001 at the first annual BWE convention. >> And not nearly often enough since then! Speaking of Cantemerle, I am enjoying drinking the 2014 now. I bought one bottle a few years ago and...

stefan

Gosh, I also like them all. I place St Estephe in last place, below St Emilion.

stefan

St Innocent:

2019 Pinot noir, Shea Vineyard (4)
2019 Pinot noir, Freedom Hill Vineyard (1)
2020 Pinot noir, Shea Vineyard (1)
2021 Pinot noir, Momtazi Vineyard (4)
2022 Riesling, Freedom Hill Vineyard (2)

stefan

>>
I will probably go broke ordering wines....
>>

That's the BWE spirit, esl!

stefan

Happy 24th, BWE! Thanks, Jim, for creating this board and running it for almost a quarter of a century.

stefan

Let this be a warning to anyone contemplating buying even oldish La Lagune. Expect to buy 3 or 4. to get one that is good. If you did not buy on release, forget it and bid on something else.

stefan

The two are for trying in Texas. The 12 are for Oregon to be drunk down the road.

stefan

12 more 2014 Pichon Baron

stefan

I am on Paxlovid, David. I haven't noticed any change in my smell or taste. I've eaten and drunk what I usually do, although in smaller amounts. Perhaps that indicates that I have no taste, confirming what Lucie tells me frequently. Lucie tested positive this morning and will probably start taking P...

stefan

Tonight we are also drinking a youngster--2007 Latour a Pomerol. It is a luscious, full bodied wine with currants and wild strawberries and a long finish, but it lacks distinctive Pomerol attributes. It should be blanquitoed, I think. How is the Lafon Rochet? I am recovering from the Covid I contrac...

stefan

Cristom spring club case
6 2022 Domaine Drouhin Louise PN
2 2014 Frank Bonneville Bl d Bl
2 2009 Paul Michel Bl d Bl
1 2010 Paul Michel Bl d Bl
1 2002 Lanson Noble
2 2014 Pichon Baron

stefan

>> If it falls apart I may have missed the opportunity to drink the remaining bottles when they were showing well. >> In the olden days, when I was young, if a good Bordeaux tasted fresh you could be sure that it would last for another ten years at least. No more. For example, some 2003 Bordeaux fel...

stefan

Looks very good, Jim. I see that you have more bottles than you did in September.

stefan

I liked the 2003s more than most people, and enjoyed them when they were young. Most 2003s have fallen apart now, and the 2002s are coming into their own. Even 2002 Latour gives pleasure now even if it will not be fully mature for 5-10 years. I found the 2002s undrinkable when they were young, but t...

stefan

That's $75 under the lowest retail price on WineSearcherPro. I'm guessing that it will be drinkable at age 20 and leaving its jailbait stage at age 30.

For only $300 more, you can buy the fabulous 1998 Ausone, which is already excellent and will probably improve for 20 years.

stefan

It is great that Farr trashed 2014!

stefan

>> I don't require financial assistance from you or from anyone else. The retailer had just one bottle on offer. >> Sorry, DavidK; that was a joke for the other David. I thought your post was by him. However, seeing as you are well heeled, I would happily take a loan for some 09 Lalande if the inter...

stefan

So how was this bottle?

Search found 6274 matches